Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsWednesday, June 24, 2026

Fantasy Football start/sit advice, TNF: Willis McGahee

McGahee has been quiet his first two weeks in Cleveland. Can he produce real value in Week 5?

Jason Miller

Cleveland Browns running back Willis McGahee enters his third game with the team looking for his first big outing. The team faces a Buffalo Bills Thursday night that has allowed a lot of yards to opposing rushers, but only one touchdown so far this season.

McGahee rushed for nine yards on eight careers in his first Browns game in Week 3, though that game came only a couple days after he signed with Cleveland. After a full week of practice, McGahee ran for 46 yards on 15 carries last Sunday against Cincinnati.

"I know I ain't Trent Richardson, but I'm here to play," McGahee told the Akron Beacon Journal, indicating the running back the Browns traded away that led to their signing of McGahee.

Fantasy impact: It’s hard to picture a situation where someone can comfortably start McGahee, even against a Bills team that is kind to running backs. Until we see that McGahee still has some burst, some elusiveness left in him, he’s a move-the-chains type that will merely pull the pile and hope he gets enough carries to matter.

Through two games, that hasn’t happened yet. It’s possible it happens in this Thursday game, but it seems more sensible to sit back and wait for McGahee to prove something before actually putting him in a lineup.

McGahee's backups, Chris Ogbonnaya and Bobby Rainey, didn't get mentioned until this last paragraph, and probably didn't even warrant that. Stay away.

More fantasy football news from SB Nation:

Get live advice daily in the Fantasy War Room

Today’s fantasy football player updates

Week 5 fantasy football rankings: QB | RB | WR | TE | D/ST

NFL
Best DFS picks for Patriots vs Texans in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Patriots vs Texans in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the Patriots and Texans

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Bears vs Rams in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Bears vs Rams in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the Bears and Rams

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Broncos vs Bills in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Broncos vs Bills in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the Broncos and Bills

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Seahawks vs 49ers in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Seahawks vs 49ers in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the 49ers and Seahawks

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Patriots-Chargers in Wild Card round matchupBest DFS picks for Patriots-Chargers in Wild Card round matchup
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Wild Card matchup between the Patriots and Chargers

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Jaguars-Bills in the Wild Card round matchupBest DFS picks for Jaguars-Bills in the Wild Card round matchup
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Wild Card DFS matchup between the Jaguars and Bills

By Chet Gresham