In Week 5 of last season, I had a decision to make. My league started three receivers (no flex), and I had to pick from a group of six: Josh Gordon, Cecil Shorts, Tavon Austin, T.Y. Hilton, Alshon Jeffery and Rueben Randle.
Fantasy football rankings 2014: Wide receivers in standard leagues
It’s position rankings time. Here’s a look at a bit of draft strategy and key names at wide receiver.


I’ll save you the time of going back and looking, but around this point of the season, these six were all considered roughly equal. They obviously delineated from one another as the season progressed, but for me, this was basically flipping a coin.
I chose Gordon, Shorts and Austin. They did okay as a group -- 22 points for Gordon, 13 for Shorts, three for Austin. Yes, Austin was awful, but a 38-point total for wide receivers is at least acceptable.
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Football
Meanwhile, my bench lit it up. Jeffery had 27 points, Hilton had 26, and Randle had 21. And I lost my matchup that week by less than a single point.
I tell that story in part to vent (because less than a point, argh), but also to illustrate part of the problem with fantasy wide receivers. We all know there are a lot of productive wide receivers in the league right now. On its surface, the fact that there are so many productive wide receivers -- Randle, Jeffery and Gordon were all taken outside of the top 30 at the position last year -- seems to mean you can wait on the position. After all, the guys I had were largely scrap-heap finds.
On the other hand, if you neglect a frontline wide receiver, as I did a year ago, you run other risks.
A whole horde of sleeper wide receivers is likely to yield many positives, guys like Jeffery and Gordon from 2013. But the first few weeks of the season will be spent wondering which ones are hitting and which are not. Hilton’s 26 points came after four or fewer points in three of his first four games. Randle put up 10 in Week 1, then five total in Weeks 2-4. Jeffery had scored 20 in Week 4, sure, but he hadn’t topped five before that; how was I to know he had become the Next Big Thing?
You can (and likely will) find some monsters at wide receiver late in the draft. But doing so will require you to be right twice: You’ll have to identify the guys in the preseason, and then you’ll have to trust your judgment enough to use those guys from the jump.
In many ways, sleepers are the key to fantasy success. That's always going to be true. But with wide receiver -- heck, with any position -- you need the studs, the Demaryius Thomases and Calvin Johnsons, to rely on before you start going full-sleeper mode.
That’s just a note on draft strategy. Now, some looks at individual players in our rankings:
Julio Jones (No. 6 receiver in our consensus rankings) -- Jones averaged 110 yards a game before his injury last year; his worst game was 76 yards on seven receptions in Week 1. This came after a sophomore 2012 in which he had 1,198 yards and 10 touchdowns. He's got top-flight pedigree and talent. The flip side of that is Jones' injury history. He was shut down last year with a repeat of a foot injury, and has played in 34 of 48 career regular season games, being limited in a few more. Jones' ceiling is as high as anyone's in the game, but his established floor comes with some worry.
Eric Decker (No. 28) - Decker was drafted in the early 20s among receivers a year ago, and rewarded his owners by finishing eighth at the position, including one of the best games of the season, a 41-point outing in Week 13. Of course, he had Peyton Manning and a cast of thousands as helpers in Denver, and is now a member of the New York Jets. That has to ding Decker, even if he is now his team's clear No. 1 instead of battling everyone in orange for touches.
Sammy Watkins (No. 34) - The Clemson rookie came into the draft with much fanfare, and going fourth overall certainly appears to line up with that. Watkins appears to be a special talent who, unfortunately for him and fantasy owners, went to Buffalo, where the opportunity to thrive might not actually be there. Long-term, he's intriguing as can be, but 2014 might not be his year.
Hakeem Nicks (No. 48) - Nicks had a weird year in 2013, putting up 896 yards with no touchdowns. It was the second-most receiving yards without a score in NFL history, behind only Al Toon's 963 yards in 1991. The lack of touchdowns made Nicks' season, which was fairly mediocre by his standards, look downright pedestrian. This despite the fact that he went for 896 yards, including three different hundred-yard games. Now a member of the Colts, Nicks is unlikely to wind up scoreless again in 2014, but he'll now be just one of many mouths to feed.
Consensus Writer Rankings
| Rank | Consensus |
| 1 | Calvin Johnson |
| 2 | Demaryius Thomas |
| 3 | Dez Bryant |
| 4 | A.J. Green |
| 5 | Brandon Marshall |
| 6 | Julio Jones |
| 7 | Jordy Nelson |
| 8 | Antonio Brown |
| 9 | Alshon Jeffery |
| 10 | Andre Johnson |
| 11 | Keenan Allen |
| 12 | Larry Fitzgerald |
| 13 | Randall Cobb |
| 14 | Vincent Jackson |
| 15 | Victor Cruz |
| 16 | Pierre Garcon |
| 17 | Roddy White |
| 18 | Wes Welker |
| 19 | DeSean Jackson |
| 20 | Percy Harvin |
| 21 | Torrey Smith |
| 22 | T.Y. Hilton |
| 23 | Michael Crabtree |
| 24 | Marques Colston |
| 25 | Cordarrelle Patterson |
| 26 | Michael Floyd |
| 27 | Mike Wallace |
| 28 | Eric Decker |
| 29 | Reggie Wayne |
| 30 | Julian Edelman |
| 31 | DeAndre Hopkins |
| 32 | Jeremy Maclin |
| 33 | Emmanuel Sanders |
| 34 | Sammy Watkins |
| 35 | Terrance Williams |
| 36 | Golden Tate |
| 37 | Kendall Wright |
| 38 | Anquan Boldin |
| 39 | Cecil Shorts |
| 40 | Mike Evans |
| 41 | Riley Cooper |
| 42 | Dwayne Bowe |
| 43 | Rueben Randle |
| 44 | James Jones |
| 45 | Marvin Jones |
| 46 | Aaron Dobson |
| 47 | Justin Hunter |
| 48 | Hakeem Nicks |
| 49 | Danny Amendola |
| 50 | Tavon Austin |
Individual Writer Rankings
| Rank | Daniel Kelley | Dan Ciarrocchi | Alex Welch | John Daigle |
| 1 | Calvin Johnson | Calvin Johnson | Calvin Johnson | Calvin Johnson |
| 2 | Demaryius Thomas | Demaryius Thomas | Dez Bryant | Brandon Marshall |
| 3 | A.J. Green | A.J. Green | Demaryius Thomas | Demaryius Thomas |
| 4 | Dez Bryant | Dez Bryant | Julio Jones | Dez Bryant |
| 5 | Brandon Marshall | Julio Jones | Brandon Marshall | Jordy Nelson |
| 6 | Antonio Brown | Brandon Marshall | AJ Green | A.J. Green |
| 7 | Jordy Nelson | Jordy Nelson | Jordy Nelson | Antonio Brown |
| 8 | Andre Johnson | Alshon Jeffery | Alshon Jeffery | Julio Jones |
| 9 | Larry Fitzgerald | Antonio Brown | Antonio Brown | Randall Cobb |
| 10 | Alshon Jeffery | Vincent Jackson | Randall Cobb | Alshon Jeffery |
| 11 | Keenan Allen | Randall Cobb | Andre Jonhson | Victor Cruz |
| 12 | Victor Cruz | Pierre Garcon | Keenan Allen | Michael Crabtree |
| 13 | Wes Welker | Victor Cruz | Larry Fitzgerald | Andre Johnson |
| 14 | DeSean Jackson | Keenan Allen | Roddy White | Keenan Allen |
| 15 | Vincent Jackson | Larry Fitzgerald | Pierre Garcon | T.Y. Hilton |
| 16 | Julio Jones | Roddy White | Vincent Jackson | Vincent Jackson |
| 17 | Roddy White | DeSean Jackson | Cordarrelle Patterson | Cordarrelle Patterson |
| 18 | Pierre Garcon | Cordarrelle Patterson | Torrey Smith | Larry Fitzgerald |
| 19 | Randall Cobb | Michael Crabtree | Wes Welker | Pierre Garcon |
| 20 | T.Y. Hilton | Andre Johnson | Victor Cruz | Wes Welker |
| 21 | Percy Harvin | Percy Harvin | Michael Floyd | Roddy White |
| 22 | Michael Floyd | Wes Welker | Marques Colston | Anquan Boldin |
| 23 | Michael Crabtree | Torrey Smith | Percy Harvin | Torrey Smith |
| 24 | Torrey Smith | Kendall Wright | DeSean Jackson | Marques Colston |
| 25 | Marques Colston | Michael Floyd | Michael Crabtree | Percy Harvin |
| 26 | Reggie Wayne | T.Y. Hilton | Mike Wallace | Eric Decker |
| 27 | Eric Decker | Mike Wallace | Julian Edelman | DeAndre Hopkins |
| 28 | Cordarrelle Patterson | Marques Colston | Kendall Wright | Kendall Wright |
| 29 | Julian Edelman | DeAndre Hopkins | TY Hilton | Julian Edelman |
| 30 | Jeremy Maclin | Julian Edelman | Terrance Williams | Emmanuel Sanders |
| 31 | Danny Amendola | Golden Tate | Eric Decker | DeSean Jackson |
| 32 | Cecil Shorts | Emmanuel Sanders | Jeremy Maclin | Reggie Wayne |
| 33 | DeAndre Hopkins | Reggie Wayne | Golden Tate | Terrance Williams |
| 34 | Terrance Williams | Cecil Shorts | Cecil Shorts | Michael Floyd |
| 35 | Mike Wallace | Eric Decker | Rueben Randle | Jeremy Maclin |
| 36 | Golden Tate | Sammy Watkins | Emmanuel Sanders | Cecil Shorts |
| 37 | Anquan Boldin | Jeremy Maclin | Sammy Watkins | Brandin Cooks |
| 38 | Kendall Wright | Marvin Jones | Dwayne Bowe | Marvin Jones |
| 39 | Mike Evans | Hakeem Nicks | Justin Hunter | Aaron Dobson |
| 40 | Sammy Watkins | Mike Evans | Reggie Wayne | Sammy Watkins |
| 41 | Dwayne Bowe | Justin Huner | Mike Evans | Mike Wallace |
| 42 | Aaron Dobson | James Jones | Aaron Dobson | Riley Cooper |
| 43 | Justin Hunter | Anquan Boldin | DeAndre Hopkins | Danny Amendola |
| 44 | Emmanuel Sanders | Riley Cooper | Greg Jennings | Dwayne Bowe |
| 45 | Andrew Hawkins | Tavon Austin | Kelvin Benjamin | Kenny Britt |
| 46 | Jerrel Jernigan | Kenny Stills | Tavon Austin | Doug Baldwin |
| 47 | Jerricho Cotchery | Kelvin Benjamin | Marvin Jones | Justin Houston |
| 48 | Brian Hartline | Rueben Randle | Riley Cooper | Marqise Lee |
| 49 | Tavon Austin | Brandin Cooks | Brandin Cooks | Golden Tate |
| 50 | Hakeem Nicks | Dwayne Bowe | Kenny Stills | Kelvin Benjamin |
| Rank | Kenneth Arthur | Scott Kaliska | Mike Gallagher |
| 1 | Calvin Johnson | Calvin Johnson | Calvin Johnson |
| 2 | AJ Green | Demaryius Thomas | Dez Bryant |
| 3 | Demaryius Thomas | Dez Bryant | Demarius Thomas |
| 4 | Julio Jones | A.J. Green | Julio Jones |
| 5 | Antonio Brown | Brandon Marshall | Brandon Marshall |
| 6 | Brandon Marshall | Julio Jones | A.J. Green |
| 7 | Dez Bryant | Alshon Jeffery | Alshon Jeffery |
| 8 | Alshon Jeffery | Antonio Brown | Andre Johnson |
| 9 | Andre Johnson | Jordy Nelson | Keenan Allen |
| 10 | Jordy Nelson | Randall Cobb | Jordy Nelson |
| 11 | DeSean Jackson | Pierre Garcon | Randall Cobb |
| 12 | Larry Fitzgerald | Keenan Allen | Antonio Brown |
| 13 | Marques Colston | Vincent Jackson | Torrey Smith |
| 14 | Vincent Jackson | Andre Johnson | Percy Harvin |
| 15 | Emmanuel Sanders | Larry Fitzgerald | Pierre Garcon |
| 16 | Victor Cruz | Victor Cruz | Larry Fitzgerald |
| 17 | Roddy White | Roddy White | Roddy White |
| 18 | Anquan Boldin | Wes Welker | DeSean Jackson |
| 19 | Wes Welker | Michael Crabtree | Vincent Jackson |
| 20 | TY Hilton | DeSean Jackson | Cordarrelle Patterson |
| 21 | Pierre Garcon | Percy Harvin | Michael Floyd |
| 22 | Reggie Wayne | Cordarrelle Patterson | Wes Welker |
| 23 | Percy Harvin | Michael Floyd | Victor Cruz |
| 24 | Sammy Watkins | Torrey Smith | T.Y. Hilton |
| 25 | Mike Wallace | T.Y. Hilton | Jeremy Maclin |
| 26 | Keenan Allen | Kendall Wright | Eric Decker |
| 27 | Torrey Smith | Mike Wallace | Sammy Watkins |
| 28 | Michael Floyd | Marques Colston | Terrance Williams |
| 29 | DeAndre Hopkins | Julian Edelman | Marques Colston |
| 30 | Randall Cobb | Eric Decker | Rueben Randle |
| 31 | Michael Crabtree | Jeremy Maclin | Michael Crabtree |
| 32 | Golden Tate | Golden Tate | Mike Evans |
| 33 | Terrance Williams | Emmanuel Sanders | DeAndre Hopkins |
| 34 | James Jones | Terrance Williams | Golden Tate |
| 35 | Riley Cooper | Reggie Wayne | James Jones |
| 36 | Mike Evans | Dwayne Bowe | Julian Edelman |
| 37 | Odell Beckham Jr | Cecil Shorts | Mike Wallace |
| 38 | Nate Washington | Sammy Watkins | Reggie Wayne |
| 39 | Brian Hartline | Riley Cooper | Kelvin Benjamin |
| 40 | Hakeem Nicks | Mike Evans | Riley Cooper |
| 41 | Stevie Johnson | Rueben Randle | Cecil Shorts |
| 42 | Steve Smith | Anquan Boldin | Marvin Jones |
| 43 | Doug Baldwin | DeAndre Hopkins | Aaron Dobson |
| 44 | Rod Streater | Hakeem Nicks | Brandin Cooks |
| 45 | Eric Decker | Marvin Jones | Dwayne Bowe |
| 46 | Dwayne Bowe | Tavon Austin | Steve Smith |
| 47 | Tavon Austin | James Jones | Justin Hunter |
| 48 | Cordarrelle Patterson | Greg Jennings | Greg Jennings |
| 49 | Jeremy Maclin | Brandin Cooks | Tavon Austin |
| 50 | Danny Amendola | Aaron Dobson | Marqise Lee |











