Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Tom Brady, DeflateGate and fantasy football

Still intent on drafting Tom Brady in your league? If so, you don’t have to look too far to find value during his suspension.

David Butler II-USA TODAY Sports

Fantasy football had its biggest news of the offseason in May with the announcement that Tom Brady will be suspended for the first four games of the 2015 NFL season. His DeflateGate suspension has a good chance of being reduced either on appeal to the commissioner or via civil lawsuit, but it remains likely that he misses at least some portion of the season. The time has come to better understand the fantasy implications.

Last season, Arian Foster missed three games and still managed to finish 2014 as the fifth overall RB. A hamstring injury caused Odell Beckham Jr. to miss the first four games of the season, but even he returned to finish the year as the fifth-highest scoring WR (and produced otherworldly on-pace numbers). Rob Gronkowski, attempting a remarkable return from a torn ACL and MCL suffered only 11 months prior, posted single-digit scoring numbers in four of his first seven outings. Needless to say, he went on to finish the season as the No. 1 TE by a mere 30 points. But absences and a lack of productivity out of the gates isn't the only thing these players have in common. All three names were also featured on at least 11 percent of rosters (the highest individual, Beckham, being 20 percent owned) that qualified for the fantasy championship last season.

How could so many owners afford to go all-in (and prosper) with only two-thirds the firepower the rest of their leagues were starting on a weekly basis? The answer is actually quite simple. No, they didn't stumble and fall on C.J. Anderson or Jeremy Hill or Mike Evans or Harry Douglas or ... well, you get the point. They just used a replacement-level player to get by.

If you had started Julian Edelman, Eric Decker, Mike Wallace, Andre Johnson or any other WR that had averaged slightly fewer than 10 points per game through the first four weeks of the season, for example, then replaced him with Beckham Jr., you were essentially getting above-average return on your investment. The same goes for those three pesky weeks that you may have been fortunate enough to slide in one of those guys from the Cleveland backfield to replace Foster. Simply put, it's in your best interest to find value where everyone else is giving it.

Before his suspension had been doled out, Tom Brady was universally coming off draft boards during the fifth round. And why not? A full season with both Gronkowski and Brandon LaFell could easily spell 4,400 yards and at least 34 touchdowns for the soon-to-be 38-year-old. And if those numbers did in fact come to fruition, a top-five finish in the QB rankings was foreseeable. Instead, we now receive an extrapolated projection of 3,400 yards and 24 touchdowns, or what Andy Dalton typically produces with a full season of work.

Fortunately, the value has only begun to show.

Since the announcement of his suspension, Brady’s ADP has sunk an entire round. Instead of being treated as the QB5 he was initially projected to be, the four-game absence has caused most to back off, leaving him in the greenroom until the ninth (and in some cases, even the 10th) round. This is where the value comes in handy.

Just yesterday, Mike Clay of Pro Football Focus wrote a terrific piece on finding value in replacement-level players. The concept isn’t anything new, but it’s worth noting again and again. It’s how our rankings are produced (with the addition of subjectivity due to the quality of replacement level) and most certainly effects the decisions we make mid-draft. Having said that, Clay also came to a simple conclusion.

Regardless of whether you took Aaron Rodgers in Round 2 or Phillip Rivers in Round 10, an absence of either player is likely to leave you starting a mid-pack QB2. For that reason, I use QB18 as a baseline for the quarterback position. A similar application of this concept to RB, WR, and TE leaves us with baselines of RB30, WR42, and TE18.

By analyzing historical and projected production at each position, we can determine expected weekly point totals from our replacement level performer. They are as follows: QB (16.0 pts), RB (8.5), WR (7.0), and TE (5.5).

With that in mind, I’ve broken down the easiest schedules through the first five weeks among those considered to be replacement-level quarterbacks. If Brady continues to fall (and I suspect he will), nabbing one of these fliers for their value alone could certainly be used to your advantage.

It should be noted, however, that this metric relies on 2014 strength of schedule information and Fantasy Football Points Allowed. The problem there is that teams that were exploitable last season (the New York Jets, for instance) could seemingly be much better in 2015, and vice versa (like the New England Patriots.) Unfortunately, we won't know actual SOS until we can properly adjust during the season. Until then, take these suggestions with a grain of salt.

First, finding value in the five most attractive replacement-level names.

Player Team Games Total FFPA to QB thru Week 5 AVG FFPA to QB thru Week 5
Sam Bradford PHI 5 86.1 17.2
Colin Kaepernick SF 5 79.5 15.9
Robert Griffin III WAS 5 79.2 15.8
Nick Foles STL 5 78.3 15.6
Jameis Winston TB 5 78 15.6

Though Nick Foles is listed with the fourth-easiest schedule among replacements, I wouldn't touch him. Not only would he be unusable Week 1 against the Seattle Seahawks, but he also travels to Arizona (whom I expect to bounce back) and Green Bay during Weeks 4 and 5. No thanks. Instead, focus more on Carson Palmer, who came in as an Honorable Mention. The metric claims Palmer faces on average only a slightly harder defense than Winston through the first five weeks (15.6 to 15.4), but really, we can depend on regression from the San Francisco 49ers (Week 3) and Detroit Lions (Week 5) due to offseason departures.

Of course, there are also these replacements you should be wary of.

Player Team Games Total FFPA to QB thru Week 5 AVG FFPA to QB thru Week 5
Marcus Mariota TEN 4 55.9 13.9
Andy Dalton CIN 5 71.1 14.2
Blake Bortles JAC 5 74.8 14.9
Geno Smith/Ryan Fitzpatrick NYJ 4 60.8 15.2
Joe Flacco BAL 5 76.3 15.2

Direct any questions (or replacement concerns) you may have to the comments and I’ll respond to them as quickly as possible.

NFL
Best DFS picks for Patriots vs Texans in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Patriots vs Texans in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the Patriots and Texans

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Bears vs Rams in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Bears vs Rams in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the Bears and Rams

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Broncos vs Bills in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Broncos vs Bills in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the Broncos and Bills

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Seahawks vs 49ers in Divisional roundBest DFS picks for Seahawks vs 49ers in Divisional round
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Divisional round DFS matchup between the 49ers and Seahawks

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Patriots-Chargers in Wild Card round matchupBest DFS picks for Patriots-Chargers in Wild Card round matchup
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Wild Card matchup between the Patriots and Chargers

By Chet Gresham
NFL
Best DFS picks for Jaguars-Bills in the Wild Card round matchupBest DFS picks for Jaguars-Bills in the Wild Card round matchup
NFL

Chet Gresham takes us through his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Wild Card DFS matchup between the Jaguars and Bills

By Chet Gresham