MLB 2014 NLDS preview: Cardinals vs. Dodgers
The Cardinals have dominated the new millennium, but this time it’s the Dodgers’ turn to move on.
I just woke up after a long coma. Who are these people?
Welcome back and congratulations on your recovery. You didn't miss much. However, you probably should stay awake for the Division Series battle between the Cardinals and Dodgers that begins on Friday.
Well, my memory is also impaired.
The Cardinals have been a perennial contender this century, with playoff appearances in 11 of 15 seasons going back to 2000. They've been to the World Series four times in that span, winning twice. They lost to the Red Sox last year. They're back in the mix again and the Red Sox, a terrific organization, aren't, which shows just how good the Cardinals are at what they do -- even if it was more of a struggle this year due to declining offense and pitching injuries.
The Dodgers are simultaneously a veteran team and the new kids with something to prove. They haven't been to the World Series since their winning effort way back in 1988, and though they made it as far as the Championship Series round a couple of times under Joe Torre, they had a rough few years as the Frank and Jamie McCourt ownership and marriage imploded, taking one of the game's jewel franchises down with it. No October baseball, but fresh-cut flowers for every office! They made it back to the NLCS last year, and they return with their mix of younger stars like Yasiel Puig and Clayton Kershaw and salty older guys such as Zack Greinke, Hanley Ramirez, and Carl Crawford.
Both teams are somewhat pitching-impaired after their first couple of starters, so the longer this series goes the less predictable it will be.
There must be some mistake. Don't the Cardinals have a starting rotation so deep that they could afford to tell Shelby Miller to go to blazes a year ago at this time?
They did. As Dylan sang, things have changed. Adam Wainwright was excellent as always, a likely owner of a couple of Cy Young Awards in any league that didn't have Clayton Kershaw (though perhaps Johnny Cueto and a few others would have something to say about that) and Lance Lynn had the most consistent seasons of his career. Everyone else was problematic or hurt. The biggest blow came when last year's rookie sensation Michael Wacha suffered a stress fracture in his pitching shoulder and basically disappeared from mid-June on. He's back now, but has been remanded to the bullpen for this series; he just hasn't had time to rebuild his endurance or rediscover his changeup.
With Wacha shelved and everyone else painting in various shades of depression blue, general manager John Mozeliak traded for veterans John Lackey and Justin Masterson. Neither really worked out (Masterson was a disaster), but given Wacha's issues, the Cardinals don't have much choice but to give Lackey a Game 3 start. As for Miller, the Cardinals are fortunate the cat came back. He had a strong finish -- he chalked up quality starts in six of his final seven starts -- and will go in Game 4 if things get that far.
And the Dodgers? What happens after Kershaw and Greinke? Fernando Valenzuela? Don Sutton? Carl Erskine?
Wow, your memory really is impaired. Erskine would be a good choice if he wasn’t 87 years old. What remains to be seen is if he’d be a better choice than Kershaw on short rest. The latter might be what happens if the series hits Game 4. Kershaw (or, as he is more accurately referred to in the scientific literature, “Superman”) will pitch Game 1 and Greinke will take the ball in Game 2. Lefty Hyun-jin Ryu has been suffering from shoulder inflammation (this after strained buttocks put him on the disabled list in mid-August), but made it through a simulated game on Wednesday and will get a chance to start Game 3.
After that, manager Don Mattingly has a choice between Kershaw and the Soup of the Day. Unlike Mozeliak, who acquired pitchers who had at least some history of above-average work (Masterson was outstanding in both 2011 and 2013; Lackey had an ERA title in the distant past and did solid, journeyman-like work for the Red Sox in both '13 and '14 after 2012 Tommy John surgery), Dodgers GM Ned Colletti responded to the loss of Josh Beckett (a blow) and Paul Maholm (a blessing) with the acquisition of journeyman Roberto Hernandez and sub-journeyman Kevin Correia.
According to ERA+, Correia is on the short list for worst pitching career of all time given his number of innings. With those options, it’s not surprising Mattingly might push Kershaw, even though Dan Haren has been announced for now as the Game 4 starter. Correia won’t even be on the postseason roster, just so no one can give in to the temptation to self-immolate.
So Ned Colletti is still pretty much like I remember him.
Right. Well, no, not exactly. One of the smartest moves of this season, in fact of the last calendar year give or take, was a move Colletti didn't make. While everyone in the sporting press sweated how the Dodgers would divide four outfielders (Yasiel Puig, Andre Ethier, Matt Kemp, Carl Crawford) into three positions and tried to predict who would be benched or traded, Colletti hung fire, holding on to the lot. It turned out the Dodgers would need all four and Mattingly, through some combination of planning, disrupting injuries, and luck, was able to juggle them until he found a winning combination.
The Dodgers had the best aggregate outfield production on the circuit, but it was rarely the same guys in the same alignment doing the work. No player got more than 89 starts at any one outfield position. Crawford, hitting a painfully expensive .244/.282/.358 through the end of July, hit .373/.411/.520 the rest of the way. Kemp hit .248/.306/.418 and seemed to spend most of his time complaining about not playing center field, but Mattingly coolly ignored the latter and kept playing him on the wings. He was rewarded with .303/.363/.545 rates over the last two-thirds of the season.
What’s a “Pweeg?”
Yasiel Puig, the remaining outfielder. Though not as consistently amazing as in his rookie season -- he was quite streaky, in fact -- he was still one of the ten most-valuable players in the league, whether via WAR (any war) or the eye test. A deep August cold snap caused one columnist to suggest he should be benched. Recency bias is a very difficult thing for the human mind to overcome. It was a risible suggestion; this guy may make mistakes, but he’s good.
Yasiel Puig (Richard Mackson-USA TODAY Sports).
I've heard that run-scoring has been way down. Can I expect some offense in this series, or is this going to be like the return of the Deadball era? I'm just old enough to have attended the 1906 World Series, won by the "Hitless Wonder" White Sox, and I'm really not anxious to relive that experience.
I'm beginning to comprehend the nature of your medical difficulties, and I just want to say that I'm thrilled to have you back, Captain America. Insofar as your question, neither team is as bad as all that, but your perception may vary depending on which side is hitting. In addition to the outfielders, the Dodgers were offensively soft at only one position, catcher, and even if A.J. Ellis isn't hitting he's willing to take ball four. The Cardinals didn't really hit well all season. Some, like Matt Holliday (.281/.367/.515), came on in the second half, but they were offset by others, like Matt Adams (.235/.291/.358) who disappeared completely.
Thank goodness we can count on those good starting pitchers you mentioned to throw a strong nine innings, then.
Well, no. We use relievers now. Unfortunately, neither team's bullpen was particularly great. The Dodgers seem to use Brian Wilson as a set-up guy mainly because he used to be somebody famous, but closer Kenley Jansen strikes out a ton of batters and had a 90 percent conversion rate this year. The Cards' virginal closer Trevor Rosenthal saw his command vanish in his new role, and though he saved 45 games, putting men on base against a deep lineup like the Dodgers' is a recipe for memorable late-game turnarounds -- in all the wrong ways.
So who is going to win this thing?
Anything can happen in a short series, Cap. The Cardinals are long on experience, but they were last in the NL in home runs, second to last in stolen bases, and the rotation looks doubtful. The Dodgers have their own problems with pitching depth, but if Kershaw can successfully double up, they have a distinct advantage in this series. Dodgers in four.



















