Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsWednesday, July 22, 2026

Better Demaryius Thomas Catch: Peyton Manning’s 400th TD Or Playoffs Game-Winner?

Demaryius Thomas of the Denver Broncos has had two pretty huge touchdown receptions: the one in overtime to beat the Steelers a year ago, and Peyton Manning’s 400th touchdown pass. Which one did he like the best?

Getty Images

Demaryius Thomas had turned out to be quite the playmaker for the Denver Broncos. A season ago it was an 80-yard touchdown reception on the first play over overtime to lift the Broncos over the Pittsburgh Steelers. That was the longest overtime touchdown in NHL playoff history, while simultaneously pushing back the actual usage of the NFL's new overtime rules. Then there's Week 1 of this season, when Thomas hauled in a catch-and-run that took him 71 yards for Peyton Manning's 400th touchdown pass.

Both were obviously awesome plays, but which one means more to Thomas? Sports Radio Interviews transcribed an interview with Thomas from 102.3 The Ticket in Denver in which he addresses the question.

“That’s tough. I’m going to have to go with the overtime play. [Host: Why? Because it meant more?] End of the game. First play of overtime. First time going to the playoffs in the NFL. I think I am going to have to go with that one. Also you gotta go up against catching Peyton Manning’s 400th touchdown pass, so it’s tough, but I think I am going to go with the end of the game one.”

Thomas also noted that Manning kept the ball from that 400th touchdown pass (it would be pretty inconsiderate of him to try and keep the other ball, considering he wasn’t with the Broncos last season). Thomas also speaks to how good it is to play with a quarterback like Peyton Manning, and breaks down what happened on the 71-yard touchdown reception, so definitely check out the full interview.

For more on the Denver Broncos, head on over to Mile High Report. You can also catch up on news around the league at SB Nation’s main NFL hub.

Check out the SB Nation Channel on YouTube

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
NFL fans predict the NFC division winnersNFL fans predict the NFC division winners
NFL

NFL fans pick the winners of each division in the NFC

By Mark Schofield
From SBNationExternal Link
Who will be a surprise Wild Card team?Who will be a surprise Wild Card team?
From SBNationExternal Link
NFL
NFL Training Camp 2026: Start dates and locations for all 32 teamsNFL Training Camp 2026: Start dates and locations for all 32 teams
NFL

Football is back (kind of).

By James Dator
NFL
6 NFL rookies taken outside the 1st round who could be ROY candidates6 NFL rookies taken outside the 1st round who could be ROY candidates
NFL

These players didnt’t get top-billing in the draft, but could easily surprise.

By James Dator
NFL
The Skinny Post: Who is facing pressure to win the Super Bowl in the 2026-27 NFL seasonThe Skinny Post: Who is facing pressure to win the Super Bowl in the 2026-27 NFL season
NFL

RJ Ochoa and Michael Peterson break down the NFL teams facing pressure in 2026-27 to just win, reach the playoffs, go deep, and win the Super Bowl.

By David Fucillo
NFL
NFL starting QBs ranked by analytics before 2026 seasonNFL starting QBs ranked by analytics before 2026 season
NFL

Breaking down every QB by overall rating and tier.

By James Dator