Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, June 19, 2026
James Dator
StarStaff

Who would be the most feel-good Super Bowl winner?

The New York Knicks prevailed in the NBA Finals, ending a drought that has lasted over 50 years. Now we turn our attention to the NFL to imagine what Super Bowl winner would bring a smile to your face, even as the most ardent hater?

For me, it has to be the Buffalo Bills. There's a specific Knicks-esque level of pain, promise, and possibility that has seen the Bills continually miss out on hoisting the Lombardi -- even when it seems they had everything needed to win.

Like the Knicks, they also have a fanbase that has never wavered from showing up, believing that it could be their year, then seeing it all crumble. Do you agree? Would the Bills be the best feel-good winner in the NFL, or is there another team you think is more deserving?

Sign in to reply to James Dator

James Dator
Poll

Which fictional quarterback would you have lead your team?

Closes in 6 days • 106 total votes
RJ Ochoa

Eli Manning or Lionel Messi

What was the first game you ever watched?

gif

Who would be the most feel-good Super Bowl winner?

Mark Schofield
Poll

Who wins the AFC North?

Closed • 258 total votes
Mark Schofield
Poll

Who won the Myles Garrett trade?

Closed • 363 total votes
Mark Schofield
Poll

Who wins the AFC East?

Closed • 90 total votes
RJ Ochoa

Who is on your dynasty team right now?