Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsMonday, August 10, 2026

Here’s a reasonable take comparing Eli Manning to LeBron James

Hear him out.

New York Giants v Washington Redskins
New York Giants v Washington Redskins
Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images

You never thought you’d hear somebody compare Eli Manning to LeBron James — and yet, here we are.

Monday, on NFL Network’s Good Morning Football, Giants defensive tackle Damon Harrison (whose beautiful nickname is “Snacks”), compared his quarterback to the NBA’s best player, but not in the way that you’d expect.

“Eli, when you look at Eli, it’s kind of like when you look at LeBron [James],” Harrison said. “I’m not saying they’re the same, but look at Eli’s numbers. If any other quarterback would have those numbers, it would be an amazing year. But it being Eli, no one is respecting it much like we do LeBron. LeBron could average 30 [points], 15 rebounds and 12 assists and it’s like ‘he didn’t do enough.’”

Harrison’s comparison came when discussing the NFL Network’s Top 100 Players of 2017 list, which Manning was not included on. “It makes no sense [that Manning wasn’t on the list] when at the same time we’ve got rookies from last year ... which I guess makes sense if you go off the year alone.”

That’s not so much of a hot take as it would have been if Harrison was trying to call Manning the best player in the NFL, or some type of freak athlete. Because overall, James and Manning are two very different athletes.

Eli is a fine quarterback. He’s won two Super Bowls, one against an 18-0 Patriots team in a game nobody expected the Giants to win. But we know him best for the funny faces he makes during games.

Like this one:

Or this one:

LeBron James is going to go down as one of the best basketball players to ever play the game. Some people will tell you that he already is. We’re not here to debate that though.

One thing nobody can debate is that he is one of the greatest athletes to walk the planet. In that sense, he and the youngest Manning are very different.

Manning’s not throwing down a hammer like this, or making a play close to being nearly as athletic. Which is fine.

James is a monster athlete who most people on the planet could never envision being like. Manning is not. They both put up performances that can go underappreciated because more is expected out of them for being better than the average player in their respective sports.

Based on that, Eli Manning and LeBron James are similar. But that’s it.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Larry Fitzgerald’s Hall of Fame induction is 25 years in the makingLarry Fitzgerald’s Hall of Fame induction is 25 years in the making
NFL

Cardinals’ Hall of Fame wide receiver has looked like a star since high school

By Bill Williamson
NFL
Best DFS picks for Cardinals vs Panthers in Hall of Fame GameBest DFS picks for Cardinals vs Panthers in Hall of Fame Game
NFL

Nick Simon brings you his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Thursday night preseason battle.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Stefon Diggs fantasy football outlook: What Commanders signing means for 2026Stefon Diggs fantasy football outlook: What Commanders signing means for 2026
NFL

Can Stefon Diggs help your fantasy team this year?

By Mark Schofield
NFL
Caleb Williams went from viral embarrassment to perfect passes at Bears training campCaleb Williams went from viral embarrassment to perfect passes at Bears training camp
NFL

Caleb Williams’ improved accuracy was on display in a training camp drill he failed at last year

By Ricky O'Donnell
NFL
7 standout players from NFL training camp so far7 standout players from NFL training camp so far
NFL

These guys are killing it in training camp

By James Dator